Tuesday, June 2, 2015

The Challenges of Ongoing Course Development

Reconstruction of the Arch of Titus in the Circus Maximus.  Source:  http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/europe/italy/11638975/Massive-triumphal-marble-arch-built-by-Romans-to-honour-Emperor-Titus-discovered.html
As is my early morning ritual, I was browsing my Twitter feed while trying to wake up the other day.  I paused on an interesting post: the remains of a second Arch of Titus had been excavated in the eastern end of the Circus Maximus.  This is pretty big news.  We knew this arch existed and even had a copy of its dedicatory inscription, but to actually find large pieces of it is kind of exciting.  In my field of classics, we don't often find the remains of famous monuments.  Intrigued, I read the news articles and, over the next days, several blog posts about the find and its significance.
Remains of the Arch of Titus in the Circus Maximus.  Source: http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/europe/italy/11638975/Massive-triumphal-marble-arch-built-by-Romans-to-honour-Emperor-Titus-discovered.html

Remains of the Circus Maximus



Finding these blocks of marble doesn't actually change anything for ancient historians.  The arch's existence was documented in medieval sources, which also preserved its dedication to Titus.  We know that it remained standing until the 12th century, when the Circus Maximus was converted to agricultural use and inhabited.  The arch was used to provide support for an aqueduct that provided water to the fields in the Circus Maximus.  It was assumed that, around this time, the arch was plundered for building materials.  Once the arch is reconstructed, we will have a better sense of its fate.  We will be able to see how much of it remained intact until it was buried; and, possibly, the archaeological context will provide additional information.

One of the great things about an online class is the ease with which they can be updated and modified.  If I had produced a printed textbook, there would be nothing to do except keep a list of updates for a second edition.  With the Online Rome class, I can make revisions in minutes.  The discovery of this second Arch of Titus is exactly the sort of thing that I will add to my version of the course.  Confession: although I am a very good classicist and ancient historian, I don't know everything.  I didn't actually know that Titus had two arches constructed in his honor by his brother and successor, Domitian.  More to the point, the current version of Online Rome perpetuates the traditional "textbook" narrative: the Arch of Titus at the start of the Roman Forum, near the Flavian Amphitheater, is a triumphal arch that commemorates Titus's victory over the Jews and Judea.

In reading the articles and blog posts about the newly discovered Arch of Titus in the Circus Maximus, I realized that this traditional narrative is wrong in some important ways.  The best source for understanding how the two Arches of Titus related is the detailed discussion on The History Blog.  A couple of important details: first, it is this Arch of Titus at the entrance of the ancient Circus Maximus (an arena where chariot races were held) that was, in fact, the triumphal arch for Titus's victory over the Jews.  It was dedicated to Titus by the Roman Senate soon after Titus's untimely death.  The dedication makes clear that the arch was erected in honor of Titus's military victory over the Jews and his sack of Jerusalem.  This is the arch's dedicatory inscription:

Senatus populusque Romanus imp(eratori) Tito Ceasari divi Vespasiani f(ilio) Vespasiani Augusto pontif(ici) max(imo), trib(unicia) pot(estate) x, imp(eratori) XVII, [c]o(n)s(uli) VIII, p(atri) p(atriae), principi suo, quod praeceptis patri(is) consiliisq(ue) et auspiciis gentem Iudaeorum domuit et urbem Hierusolymam, omnibus ante se ducibus regibus gentibus aut frustra petitam aut omnino intem(p)tatam, delevit.

The Senate and People of Rome [dedicate this arch] to the Emperor Titus [snip many titles], because by his father’s counsel and good auspices, he conquered the people of Judaea and destroyed the city of Jerusalem, which all of the generals, kings, and peoples before him had either failed to do or even to attempt.

 The Arch of Titus at the start of the Via Appia in the Roman Forum, by contrast, is not a standard triumphal arch despite the allusions to Titus's victory over the Jews in some of the relief panels.  As The History Blog post observes, "The central panel in the single arch’s soffit relief depicts Titus being carried to the heavens by an eagle. The inscription also emphasizes the recently deceased emperor’s divinity: “SENATUS/ POPULUSQUE ROMANUS/ DIVO TITO DIVI VESPASIANI F(ilio)/ VESPASIANO AUGUSTO” (The Senate and People of Rome [dedicate this arch] to the divine Titus Vespasian Augustus, son of the divine Vespasian)." 


Source: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Triumphal_arch
This second Arch of Titus was erected in 82 by Domitian and, like the first arch, was dedicated to the memory of the deified Titus by the Roman Senate.  Note the much less elaborate inscription in the second arch, the omission of Titus's many titles and offices.  This second arch is clearly not a standard victory arch but rather, a kind of celebratory arch that, as much as anything, celebrates the divinity of Vespasian and Titus; and helps to legitimate Domitian's status as their successor.  But how, exactly, are we to understand the meaning and occasion of this second, surviving Arch of Titus?  How would a Roman living during Domitian's rule have understood these two arches?  How would their relationship have been conceptualized?

It is interesting to observe that Titus's official triumphal arch was erected at the entrance of the Circus Maximus, a public space for entertainment.  This choice seems especially meaningful when we remember that it was the Flavians who constructed the massive Flavian Amphitheater (Colosseum), not too distant from the Circus Maximus.  In fact, Domitian would make significant renovations to the massive Amphitheater and held elaborate games to re-inaugurate it.  So why erect a second arch to his deceased brother on the edge of the Roman Forum?  Suddenly, the Arch of Titus in the Roman Forum, a monument that seemed to have a straightforward story to tell, becomes complicated.  Suddenly, the traditional treatment of the extant Arch of Titus as a victory arch is not so easy to defend. 

In this instance, a historian more versed than I am about Flavian archaeology might have discussed the two arches in the first place.  Nobody knows everything, however, and the brilliance of the digital medium is the ease of revision.  It forgives ignorance and allows easy correction.  At the same time, important questions are raised by an online course that never come up when an instructor is teaching from a printed textbook: who is responsible for keeping an online course updated, especially if the original designer is no longer involved in the project?  Is it the responsibility of the course coordinator?  Should someone be brought in to provide updates and revisions to the content every year or two?

In my field of Classics, the number of necessary updates is likely to be fairly small compared to something like Contemporary US Government.  Still, the original course cannot be left unrevised for years.  There are new discoveries as well as new theories of old evidence every year.  One of the reasons it is so important to have a content expert continuously involved with the running of the course is precisely that someone needs to stay aware of these new findings in the field (and be able to understand the significance of the new findings). 

People frequently compare online courses to textbooks.  In some ways, they do function like enhanced textbooks.  They nevertheless differ from textbooks in some important ways, most especially in the fact that they are organic and can be modified.  In addition, at least in my Online Rome course, there is no "textbook author" voice that is distinct from the voice of the instructor.  From the perspective of the student, there is only the voice of the instructor; and the instructor can modify the modules as they wish, to reflect their own expertise and interests (within reason).  An online course is a kind of living creature.  It is never "finished"; it can be and should be constantly updated, added to, subtracted from.

I don't know if this will happen, but it is my hope that, even after the course has been handed off to the Classics Department to run, that the course coordinator as well as the instructors will continue to work on the content, adding something here and taking away something there.  Perhaps they might have a new idea for a game.  Although the course I handed over is complete, polished, and ready to go, I hope that future instructors will recognize that one of the benefits of the digital medium is the ability to make modifications and corrections. 

I imagine coming back to the class in a decade to find that Online Rome has continued to evolve over that time to adapt to the needs of students; incorporate new content (new discoveries or theories of existing evidence but also, e.g., videos, animations, virtual reality experiences, and games); and incorporate new learning tools as they become available.  It is important that everyone involved with the course recognize the opportunity they have to put their own mark on the course; but also, the responsibility to ensure that it is regularly and systematically updated.  With every passing month, it seems, there is more and more content available, some of it very good.

For instance, I just noticed that the MAV, a museum which creates virtual reality experiences from archaeological remains, has just posted a reconstruction of the baths at Herculaneum.  The MAV page on Facebook is a great resource for these virtual reconstructions (they also have reconstructed the Villa of the Papyri), especially because it is nearly impossible for students to imagine what ancient bath complexes looked like from the scant remains that we can show them.  These reconstructions allow them to imagine the scale and magnificence of the original public buildings.  Keeping track of new digital content and deciding what to integrate into the course will be an essential role of the course coordinator (or someone).  Without revisions, additions, and modifications, Online Rome will indeed function more like a textbook--a stable object that slowly becomes outdated in a range of ways.

36 comments:

  1. Yes yes yes yes, a hundred times yes! Plus, there is all the content that can and should be added / updated as a result of interactions with students, finding out what they are excited about, confused about, and so on. Meanwhile, thanks for all the news here. It makes me want to take a trip to Rome just to be in the presence of all those STONES. :-)

    ReplyDelete
  2. Jen,

    I've been working on open source software to help individuals create courses independently of a university. CyberCourse - aka Cyco - supports learning science ideas, like frequent formative feedback, deep learning through patterns and big ideas, and much else. It also makes content easy to change. That was a design goal from the beginning.

    If you're interested, it's at https://cybercour.se. It's a work-in-progress, though I use it for live courses. An example is at https://programming.cybercour.se

    Regards,
    Kieran

    ReplyDelete
  3. Right, Laura--a major advantage of the digital is the ability to modify on the fly. So, for instance, every semester I teach f2f, certain topics generate more interest than others. It's important to find ways to highlight those (usually by cutting back on something else). Or to re-emphasize at later points topics that are still confusing. These are all possible to do in a "built" class so long as everyone understands that "built" is not the equivalent of stable, immutable artifact. Teaching really is a very intricate dance; and the digital allows us so much more flexibility than does a printed textbook. At the same time, it requires an instructor who has the skill to leverage the advantages of proffered by the digital. It's interesting: as I wrote about aspects of the online class, I find myself coming back over and over to the same thing--everything ultimately comes down to the skill and expertise of the instructors. Just like in a f2f class.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Thank you very much. I agreee with your article, this really helped me. I appreciate your help. Thanks a lot. Good website.
    Lifting Supervisors Course

    ReplyDelete
  5. Nice post, thanks for sharing. our qualified development team is expert in changing the look and feel of the open source LMS. We install, customize and develop new functionalities as per the requirements. This way the canvas LMS development has personalized and unique looks for each customer. If you need any help from us email at: info@cryptextechnologies.com

    ReplyDelete
  6. SMO advancement is moderately similarly significant. SMO Services now has become an imperative piece of expanding on the web brand mindfulness. It is an unimaginable method if applies appropriately for the business would acquire gigantic changes in the development of the business by driving the referral traffic on the site. SMO benefits in India or over the world are viably and adroitly utilizing by computerized advertisers for inspiring their business. Different SMO models are there that show it is the best method for expanding the compass and pulling in potential clients.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I am a QuickBooks user and facing a mistake within it. My QuickBooks won't open, and this is often hampering my work. I’m unable to use my QuickBooks and this is often making me unable to manage my financial works. Is anybody conscious of the difficulty and its solution? If you recognize the way to solve this QuickBooks won't open issue, let me skills I can solve this error in my system. The error in QuickBooks also making my PC slow and therefore the Windows is responding slowly with the mouse and keyboard command.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I am unable to download AOL desktop Gold for Windows 10 PC, so please suggest me easy tips for the AOL desktop gold download process. Please share your opinion here.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Having rich industrial experience and knowledge of the real estate and related industry, we are serving our customers with outstanding services. Due to hard work, passion, and dedication towards works, we are acclaimed as the Real Estate Investment Funds
    in the market. If you are seeking such services, then contact us at any time and avail of the service.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Are you facing trouble with your HP scanner? Do not worry; you will find a solution here. We have a team of experts and professionals who can help you resolve your HP scanner not working error. Primarily, the reason behind this issue is corrupted driver software, and to upgrade it you can visit 123.hp.com/setup webpage. You just need to go to the Support section and click download the drivers. Make sure to choose the full package instead of the basic one. Another reason is the incorrect firewall settings, and to rectify it, you will need to visit the control panel on your computer and select Windows Defender Firewall. Further, you can click on Allow an app through windows defender firewall and then checkmark the HP scanner application, to permit the scanning operations. For advanced troubleshooting, you must contact our printer and scanner experts to fix the problem.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Get it completed from the Top notch Assignment Writers for the Students across Universities across various countries. With the best in class turnaround time and also avail amazing value added service, And Get in touch with the Best Assignment Help in Melbourne, Sydney, Canberra, Adelaide who are very talented in providing solutions on various topics on subjects.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Such a wonderful information blog post on this topic allassignmentservices.com provides assignment service at affordable cost in a wide range of subject areas for all grade levels, we are already trusted by thousands of students who struggle to write their academic papers and also by those students who simply want ERP Assignment Help to save their time and make life easy.

    ReplyDelete
  13. We have assisted many students in getting their assignments finished at the guaranteed time. We have never neglected to fulfill the time constraints in our set of experiences and neither do we later on. The best part about us is that, we follow the rules of the college and prerequisites of students to make the assignments that are liberated from syntactic blunders. From research about the theme to the writing style to editing of the composed substance, everything is done consummately by our specialists. cheap assignment help
    write my assignment

    ReplyDelete
  14. Hire premium quality do my assignment services only at best assignment experts and get your work done at affordable rates. We understand students find it extremely difficult to hire expensive services. Hence, best assignment experts delivers assignment help at low rates to make it easier for students.Do My Assignment

    ReplyDelete
  15. Am definitely glad that I found this page. It is quite a unique blog with fantastic ideas. I will come back for more ideas. U.S. Tourist Visa

    ReplyDelete
  16. Thanks for posting this magnificent info. I was looking for this info. Thanks once again. Checkout Stem Subjects Philippines

    ReplyDelete
  17. Excellent post! You may get the best Managerial Economics Assignment assistance from the professional site Assignmenthelped. The application of management and economic concepts is the focus of managerial economics. Managerial Economics Assignment Help is available from our team of experts. Managerial Economics Assignment Help

    ReplyDelete
  18. Thank you very much. I agreee with your article, this really helped me. Hot Water Drinking Benefits

    ReplyDelete
  19. This is really helpful post, very informative there is no doubt about it. Kashmir Houseboat Price

    ReplyDelete
  20. Thanks for sharing. Nice blog. Assignment Firm service provides all college students with the Best AssignmentHelp service. Our experts provide 100% plagiarism-free content for college and university students. Thank you.

    ReplyDelete
  21. Business Economics is a fast economics course that focuses on budget management and consistently provides excellent assignment answers. Students should contact assignment writers as soon as feasible for quick assignment assistance since authors will complete the work as soon as possible after getting the feedback. Business Economics Assignment Help

    ReplyDelete
  22. It’s clearly and valid ideas shared; I believe its useful world while. Nice effort! Thank you for sharing. visit us: how to get ICAN past questions pdf format

    ReplyDelete
  23. Thanks for sharing, Sample assignment has an experienced team of assignment experts who works with the motive to enhance the academic grades of students through their Synthesis Essay.

    ReplyDelete
  24. Psychology is one of the most difficult disciplines that college students study. It is concerned with human behavior, mental health, and mental disorders. It is one of the most esoteric subjects, yielding virtually little information on how the human mind works. To cope with the papers efficiently, we supply you with the greatest health psychology assignment help. Students can reduce their writing stress by connecting to our specialists. We guarantee that we will supply you with the greatest answer answers that will get you top ratings. Our professionals are available to assist you at a reasonable cost to all students.

    ReplyDelete

  25. Great Blog For Qatar university Student, which is preparing the exam. Assignment Help Qatar can supply the correct response to difficult queries. As a result, assignment assistance can help students achieve great grades.

    ReplyDelete
  26. good information. To read my blog go to the link
    https://healthylifehuman.com/remove-makeup-at-home/

    ReplyDelete
  27. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  28. I realized I was thoroughly absorbed in the subject and couldn't put down the electronic book.
    . guides on how to get wrinkles out of leather

    ReplyDelete
  29. Great Post! Inspired by this post. Thanks for sharing. Stress and confusion are common when writing any research-oriented assignment. As the best Online Assignment Help Belfast Service provider, we provide phenomenal tasks without skipping deadlines. We ensure you with 100% confidence so you can stay stress-free by hiring our assignment helpers in Belfast. So, if you are stressed with your assignment work, come to us and kick off your worries.

    ReplyDelete
  30. Your content never fails to amaze us , appreciate your skill.
    We have been helping students in their academics for a long time . Students receive an expert written Dissertation help and more. We as team ensure to deliver the most authentic and error proof work to our clients.

    ReplyDelete
  31. Looking for reliable dissertation proofreading services in the UK? Our expert team offers top-notch editing and proofreading solutions for your academic masterpiece. Get polished results today

    ReplyDelete
  32. Help with Matlab assignment excels at handling data and provides a variety of tools for data analysis and visualization. Assignments in this area may involve tasks like processing, manipulating, and visualizing data sets using MATLAB's built-in functions, plotting graphs, and creating visual representations. MATLAB is widely used for control systems and simulations. Assignments in this area may involve modeling and simulating dynamic systems, designing and analyzing control systems, or implementing. Optimization and Algorithm Development: MATLAB provides powerful tools for optimization and algorithm development. Assignments may include tasks like implementing optimization algorithms, solving optimization problems, or developing new algorithms for specific applications.

    ReplyDelete
  33. Cheap assignment help in the UK is a lifeline for students facing tight budgets or struggling with challenging coursework. These services offer expert guidance and support at affordable rates, making it accessible to a wide range of students. Here, we delve into the world of cheap assignment help and explore how it benefits students across the United Kingdom. The primary advantage of opting for Cheap Assignment Help UK is its cost-effectiveness. Students often have limited financial resources, and the burden of expensive academic assistance can add to their stress. Cheap assignment help services understand these constraints and offer reasonably priced solutions that fit within students' budgets. This accessibility ensures that every student can access the help they need without breaking the bank.

    ReplyDelete
  34. This insightful blog sheds light on the persistent challenges in ongoing courses. As a nursing student, I appreciate the valuable perspectives shared. For further assistance, consider Programming Assignment Help from Assignment Help Pro.

    ReplyDelete